Hot Picks

- Ready for My Close Up 2019

- Talk of the Dead 2016

- Exit 0 2019

- One Missed Call 2003

- Carol of the Bells 2019

- Axeman Redux 2020

- Feedback 2019

- Day of the Stranger 2019

- The 410 2019

- Melvin the Birder 2020

- Wow Signal 2017

- H4 2012

- Cupid 2020

- Deadly Manor 1990

- The Insurrection 2020

- The Girl in the Crawlspace 2018

- Rooftops 2020

- Tapeworm 2019

- What Love Looks Like 2020

- Agramon's Gate 2020

- Lessons Learned 2020

- Help from Above 2019

- The Limits of Control 2009

- First Impressions Can Kill 2017

- Appiness 2018

- Keepsake! 2019

- Softness of Bodies 2018

- Murmur 2019

- The House by the Cemetery 1981

- Yamasong 2020

- Beyond the Law 2019

- A Stranger Among the Living 2020

- Making Faces 2019

- Psycho-Therapy 2019

- The Narrative of Victor Karloch 2020

- Shoot to Marry 2020

- A Perfect Host 2019

- Mommy 1995

- Teacher Shortage 2020

- Perfect 2020

- The Divide 2019

- Human Hibachi 2020

- The Mannequin 2020

- Bite Night 2020

- Mother 2020

- The Cannibal Killer: The Real Story of Jeffrey Dahmer 2020

- My Hindu Friend 2015

- Creation 2016

- Black Angel 1946

- The Kingdom of Var 2019

- A Killer Conversation 2014

- Star Crash 1979

- Strangler of the Swamp 1946

The Scarlet Claw

USA 1944
produced by
Roy William Neill for Universal
directed by Roy William Neill
starring Basil Rathbone, Nigel Bruce, Gerald Hamer, Paul Cavanagh, Arthur Hohl, Miles Mander, Kay Harding, David Clyde, Ian Wolfe, Victoria Horne
story by Paul Gangelin, Brenda Weisberg, screenplay by Edmund L. Hartmann, Roy William Neill, based on characters created by Arthur Conan Doyle, music by Paul Sawtell

Sherlock Holmes, Sherlock Holmes (Basil Rathbone), Universal's Sherlock Holmes

review by
Mike Haberfelner

Quick Links

Abbott & Costello

Alice in Wonderland

Arsène Lupin



Black Emanuelle

Bomba the Jungle Boy

Bowery Boys

Bulldog Drummond

Captain America

Charlie Chan


Dick Tracy

Dr. Mabuse

Dr. Orloff

Doctor Who


Elizabeth Bathory



Flash Gordon


Frankie & Annette Beach Party movies

Freddy Krueger

Fu Manchu





El Hombre Lobo

Incredible Hulk

Jack the Ripper

James Bond

Jekyll and Hyde

Jerry Cotton

Jungle Jim


Kekko Kamen

King Kong

Laurel and Hardy

Lemmy Caution


Lone Wolf and Cub

Lupin III


Marx Brothers

Miss Marple

Mr. Moto

Mister Wong


Nick Carter

OSS 117

Phantom of the Opera


Robin Hood

Santa Claus

El Santo

Schoolgirl Report

The Shadow

Sherlock Holmes


Star Trek

Sukeban Deka



Three Mesquiteers

Three Musketeers


Wizard of Oz

Wolf Man

Wonder Woman




Lady Pemrose has been killed, and her husband (Paul Cavanagh), a firm believer in the occult, is quick to blame the death on the monster of a local legend, which would prove all of his supernatural theories - but Sherlock Holmes (Basil Rathbone), Pemrose's fiercest opponent in the Occult Society, who has been called for help by Lady Pemrose prior to her demise, soon comes up with other theories, based on the facts that the so-called monster leaves the exact same marks as a common garden weeder and that Lady Pemrose once was a well-known actress. Lord Pemrose naturally opposes all of Holmes's theories, and this way behaves much too guilty to actually be the murderer ...

When crossing the marshland, Holmes is even attacked by the monster, a weirdly glowing creature, but he manages to chase it away and even finds evidence the monster was only made to glow thanks to phosphor.

Eventually, Holmes's investigations lead him to judge Brisson (Miles Mander), and with the informations the judge gives him, Holmes determines the identity of the murderer, an actor turned killer turned escapee whom both Lady Pemrose and the judge had to deal with, and who apparently has made the region his new home - thing is, he is also a master of disguise, and thus nobody knows who he actually is ...

Eventually, the judge is killed, and now Holmes concentrates on a third man who had contact to the killer, Journet (Arthur Hohl), a former prison guard turned innkeeper - and to catch the killer, Holmes sends Journet out into the marshland all alone - where Jounet is soon accompanied by harmless postman Potts (Gerald Hamer) - who out of nowhere attacks Journet with a garden weeder. But then Journet turns out to be Holmes in disguise, and he and the police chase Potts through the marshes to his death.

Nigel Bruce repeats his role as Doctor Watson and is at his most moronic - and most annoying - this time around.


Blending a typical Sherlock Homes-mystery with a monster story might sound like a good idea in writing (and it has been done successfully in Hound of the Baskervilles), but this film just fails to deliver on its promise, first and foremost because Holmes is quite simply too clever for the whole supernatural set-up and thus is way too quick to expose all that is creepy (in the occult sense of the word) as man-made pretty much on the spot. Now this plot would possibly have worked beautifully if it seemed even for a few minutes that Holmes is in it over his head and would actually have been forced to challenge his own reason, but that's quite simply never the case here, and thus the film is nothing more than another routine mystery with the typical overcomplex story setup, the wild deductions and the killer-out-of-a-hat firmly in place - and it'S not even one of the better Holmes-movies.

By the way, for some weird reason, this film claims to be set in Canada, even though everything in the plot safe for some French language names, suggests nothing but the British countryside. Oh well ...


review © by Mike Haberfelner


Feeling lucky ?
Want to
any of my partnershops yourself
for more, better results ?

The links below
will take you
just there !!!

Find The Scarlet Claw
at the amazons ...


Great Britain (a.k.a. the United Kingdom)

Germany (East AND West)

Looking for imports ?
Find The Scarlet Claw here ...

Your shop for all things Thai

Something naughty ?
(Must be over 18 to go there !)

x-rated  find The Scarlet Claw at

Thanks for watching !!!



Robots and rats,
demons and potholes,
cuddly toys and
shopping mall Santas,
love and death and everything in between,
Tales to Chill
Your Bones to

is all of that.


Tales to Chill
Your Bones to
a collection of short stories and mini-plays
ranging from the horrific to the darkly humourous,
from the post-apocalyptic
to the weirdly romantic,
tales that will give you a chill and maybe a chuckle, all thought up by
the twisted mind of
screenwriter and film reviewer
Michael Haberfelner.


Tales to Chill
Your Bones to

the new anthology by
Michael Haberfelner


Out now from




On the same day
a Burglar wants to kill you
and your Ex wants
to make up ...
... and for the life of it,
you can't decide


A Killer Conversation

produced by and starring
Melanie Denholme
directed by
David V.G. Davies
written by
Michael Haberfelner
Ryan Hunter and
Rudy Barrow

out now on DVD