Hot Picks
|
|
|
Letter of Introduction
USA 1938
produced by John M. Stahl for Universal
directed by John M. Stahl
starring Adolphe Menjou, Andrea Leeds, George Murphy, Edgar Bergen & his dummy Charlie McCarthy, Rita Johnson, Ann Sheridan, Ernest Cossart, Frank Jenks, Eve Arden, May Boley, George Davis, Jonathan Hale, Kathleen Howard, Armand Kaliz, Crauford Kent, Esther Ralston, Natalie Moorhead, William B. Davidson, Alphonse Martell, Doris Lloyd, Claire Whitney, Grace Hayle, Russell Wade, Sam Hayes
story by Bernice Boone, screenplay by Sheridan Gibney, Leonard Spigelgass, music by Frank Skinner
review by Mike Haberfelner
|
|
Available on DVD! To buy, click on link(s) below and help keep this site afloat (commissions earned) |
Always make sure of DVD-compatibility!!!
|
|
|
|
|
Kay (Andrea Leeds) has come to New York City with the intention to
become an actress, and she thinks the one letter of introduction to acting
superstar John Mannering (Adolphe Menjou) is all she needs - actually she
believes in it so much that she runs into a burning building to save the
letter, only to have to be saved herself in return - by handsome young
Barry (George Murphy), whom she pretty much immediately falls in love
with, and vice versa. But her faith in the power of her letter was
well-placed, as it identifies her as Mannering's illegitimate daughter -
and he, reading that letter is totally moved by it, as he didn't until now
know he even had a daughter, and he wants to make up for everything he
missed out on over the years. But he insists they keep her being his
daughter a secret as it could hurt his career (even if four marriages and
divorces apparently didn't) and instead claiming he's his protegée -
which though only leads to problems in both their personal lives, as
Mannering's fiancée Lydia (Ann Sheridan) dumps him pretty much on the
spot when catching him with Kay only days away from their wedding, and
Barry, seeing her spend too much time with Mannering, decides to go on a
lengthy tour with his dancing partner Honey (Rita Johnson) with the intent
of marrying her on the road. Both Kay and Mannering that it in stride and
don't really mind that they become prime fudder of the gossip press.
Eventually, Mannering tries to get Kay a role in a Broadway play, but as
everybody he talks to is more interested in him than her, he agrees to
take his first stage role in twelve years as long as Kay gets a lead as
well. And at the end of the premiere, he plans to tell everyone the truth
about Kay's identity. But he gets the jitters, and before curtain he gets
so roaringly drunk that he forgets his lines once on stage and ultimately
stumbles over furniture which causes the play to shut down
mid-performance. Kay's mad at him, and understandably so, and guilt-ridden
as he is, in addition to being drunk, Mannering runs into traffic and is
knocked over by a car soon therafter. Kay sees Mannering for one last time
on his death bed, and he dies just before he can reveal their secret to
the reporters present at the hospital. She decides to not go public with
the story, but finally tells Barry, who just happens to be in town, and of
course he ultimately gets the girl after all ... Edgar Bergen and his
dummy Charlie McCarthy have sizeable supporting roles, but don't do
anything to actually further the story. A well-acted melodrama
- that just never really manages to take off. For one it's probably
because it never finds the right balance between comedy and drama, instead
suffers from tonal shifts that hurt the film's build-up, but the more
important reason is that the conflict of the film just isn't really
palpable - basically if Kay and Mannering had the decency of telling those
closest to them about their actual relationship, then everything would be
resolved already - but apparently they intentionally choose not to, and by
their choice (as it is just that), they make the stakes in the film rather
unimportant, to a point where one questions whether it's really Kay who
deserves the happy ending with Barry rather than Honey (who's pretty much
suddenly written out of the movie when she's no longer needed). That's not
to say the film's all bad, and if vintage melodramas are at all your thing
and you're not too particular about a perfectly developed plot, you might
like this one, it's just a film that doesn't by any means live up to the
quality of its cast.
|
|
|